What You Say can and will be Used Against You

To Ms. Isabela “Isa” Casahuga Lemgru, I just hope future employers don’t do a deep dive on your media platform post and find what you said at Turning Point USA Pick Up the Mic event. Not only will those companies would be judging you but the people that conduct business with those companies that might not do business with them.

JUST Remember BUD LIGHT! Let me inform you and companies that would hired you, I would terminate all business with them.  

On September 23, 2026, at the University of Texas at San Antonio, a 19-year-old student named Isabela “Isa” Casahuga Lemgruber—who introduced herself as “Pamper Baby”—stepped to the microphone at a Turning Point USA “Pick Up the Mic” event.

The Threat Toward Mr. Collins that should be Investigated

She recited a parody of “The Night Before Christmas” that mocked the assassination of Charlie Kirk. The poem, which she said she wrote, referred to the “Kirkiversary” and “solemnly remembered a shot to the neck.” After finishing, she told the event’s speaker, Texas Youth Summit founder Christian Collins, that he was “brave” for appearing on campus “with no protection, no nothing, no like neck brace.” Collins responded that he would pray for her.

Video of the exchange, posted by Collins on October 27, quickly went viral. UTSA later confirmed it was reviewing the matter under student conduct processes.

Casahuga subsequently issued a public apology to the Kirk family and to Collins.

Kirk, the founder of Turning Point USA, was fatally shot in the neck on September 10, 2025, while taking questions at Utah Valley University.

How Cowards Handle what they Find Objectionable

Authorities identified 22-year-old Tyler Robinson as the suspect; he has been charged with aggravated murder. The “Pick Up the Mic” series continues Kirk’s practice of open campus engagement, in which anyone can approach and speak. Collins and others have framed the events as continuing that tradition of debate rather than monologue.

The episode has drawn attention because the platform was extended without precondition. TPUSA’s format is not a closed town hall limited to invited guests; it is an open microphone available to challengers. Casahuga invoked freedom of speech when she stepped forward.

That freedom, protected by the First Amendment, covers speech that is offensive, crude, or celebratory of ideas others find repugnant. It does not protect true threats or incitement to imminent violence.

The Threat

Many viewers interpreted her “neck brace” remark, delivered with evident glee after a poem that treated a fatal neck wound as a punch line, as crossing into the latter category. Collins himself described the climate as one in which such remarks occur and said the response is still to “pick up the mic anyway.”

This is not the first time political disagreement has been answered with violence rather than argument. Presidents and other officials have been assassinated while exercising rights of speech, assembly, and petition.

The three civil-rights workers murdered by the Klan in Philadelphia, Mississippi, in 1964—two Jewish, one Black—were killed while working to secure the equal rights the Declaration of Independence calls unalienable.

Those killings were rightly condemned as an attack on the principle that disputes are resolved by law and persuasion, not bullets. The same standard applies today. When a speaker offers the microphone and the response is a poem that treats an assassination as an anniversary to be marked with memes, the line between protected expression under free speech and intimidation and threats are clear.

In 1 Thessalonians 5:21 is important instructions for all of us believers and unbelievers alike, to “test everything; hold fast what is good.” Debate that rests on facts, historical record, and observable outcomes is the method the passage endorses. Substituting celebration of a killing for argument abandons that method.

The Intended Purpose of Colleges & Universities

Universities exist, among other purposes, to train students in precisely that discipline. Casahuga is a Houston native and St. Agnes Academy graduate now studying international relations and diplomacy at UTSA. She been provided the benefits of what people have worked to established, and what does she with those benefits, she trash other people and their families.

This is Expected from Liberal Ivory Leagues, but Not UTSA

The question many have asked is whether the education she and her peers are receiving equips them to meet opposing views with evidence rather than with mockery of the dead. Ivy League campuses have produced similar spectacles in recent years; the appearance of the same pattern at a large Texas public university suggests the problem is not confined to a handful of coastal institutions.

What Liberal Democrats Don’t Offer is a Open Forum to Others

Kirk’s own practice was to invite disagreement. The “Prove Me Wrong” banners and open microphones were not rhetorical flourishes; they were the operating procedure. Robinson, the accused shooter, declined that invitation and chose a rifle instead.

Casahuga accepted the microphone and used it to treat the resulting death as material for verse and taunt. Both choices reject the premise that a more perfect union is formed through peaceful argument under the rule of law.

The First Amendment protects the right to make that rejection in words. It does not obligate anyone else to treat the rejection as serious argument, nor does it shield the speaker from social, professional, or institutional consequences when the words are widely judged threatening with violence.

Remember you might very well have the right to speak your mind; but be ready to handle the consequences of those views.

The remedy remains the one the Constitution and the biblical texts both point toward: keep the microphone open, insist on evidence, and refuse to answer violence—or the celebration of violence—with either silence or more violence. That is the harder path. It is also the only one that has ever produced durable peace.